Toyota vs Honda Used SUV Comparison for Utah Shoppers

Toyota vs. Honda: Used SUV Comparison for Utah Shoppers

Shopping for a used SUV in Utah? Two names rise to the top: Toyota and Honda. Both brands are known for reliability, value, and everyday comfort. This guide compares popular pre-owned Toyota and Honda SUVs so you can pick the right fit for life along the Wasatch Front.

Used Toyota vs. Honda SUV Reliability & Longevity (RAV4, CR-V, 4Runner, Pilot)

Both lineups are built to last. Toyota SUVs (like 4Runner and Highlander) have a reputation for rugged longevity, while Honda SUVs (like CR-V and Pilot) deliver excellent long-term dependability. If you plan to keep your SUV well past 150k miles, Toyota gets a slight edge; for low-drama daily driving, Honda is equally confidence-inspiring.

Maintenance & Ownership Costs for Used Toyota and Honda SUVs in Utah

Average maintenance costs on many used Honda SUVs tend to be a touch lower, while used Toyota SUVs often see fewer major repairs over time. Either way, both brands offer affordable upkeep, widely available parts, and strong service support across Salt Lake County.

Resale Value & Total Value: Toyota RAV4/4Runner vs. Honda CR-V/Pilot

If resale value matters, Toyota usually wins by a nose thanks to its durability reputation especially on RAV4 and 4Runner. That said, CR-V and Pilot remain smart buys with excellent value retention, making both brands strong choices for trade-in down the road.

Interior Space & Family Comfort (Highlander vs. Pilot • RAV4 vs. CR-V)

  • Toyota Highlander vs. Honda Pilot (3-row SUVs): Pilot typically offers a roomier third row; Highlander counters with a refined ride and available hybrid power.

  • Toyota RAV4 vs. Honda CR-V (2-row compacts): CR-V shines for rear-seat space and cargo practicality; RAV4 brings a more adventurous feel and great trim variety.

AWD, Snow Performance & Towing for Utah Roads (AWD SUVs, 4Runner, Passport)

For winter traction on I-15 and Big Cottonwood access roads, both brands' AWD systems perform well. Need rugged ability or towing? The Toyota 4Runner (body-on-frame) is the off-road and utility champ. For light towing and highway comfort, Honda Passport/Pilot and Toyota Highlander are excellent choices.

Fuel Economy & Hybrid Options (RAV4 Hybrid vs. CR-V Hybrid • Highlander Hybrid)

Daily commuting from South Jordan to SLC? Hybrids are your friend.

  • Toyota RAV4 Hybrid and Highlander Hybrid deliver standout MPG.

  • Honda CR-V Hybrid balances efficiency with a smooth, quiet ride.
     If you prioritize fuel savings, start with these trims.

Safety & Driver Assistance: Toyota Safety Sense vs. Honda Sensing

Most newer used Toyota and Honda SUVs include advanced driver-assist tech: adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping, and automatic emergency braking. Toyota Safety Sense and Honda Sensing are both excellent-focus on the specific features and model year that matter to you (e.g., blind-spot monitor, rear cross-traffic alert).

Which Used SUV Is Right for You? (Quick Recommendations)

  • Choose Toyota if you want: top-tier longevity, excellent resale value, more off-road-ready choices (4Runner), and multiple hybrid options.

  • Choose Honda if you want: slightly lower average maintenance costs, roomy family comfort (CR-V, Pilot), and an easy, refined daily drive.

Shop Used Toyota & Honda SUVs Near Utah

Ready to compare options side by side? Browse our current pre-owned Toyota and Honda SUVs:

Our team can help you compare trims, AWD systems, towing, and hybrid vs. gas, and set up a hassle-free test drive.